How to Read a Mill Test Certificate: EN 10204 3.1 vs 3.2, and What to Check
How inspectors read a mill test certificate: EN 10204 types 2.1, 2.2, 3.1 and 3.2, what to check line by line, carbon equivalent, and common red flags.
By Syed Hasan15 Nov 20264 min read

Every pipe, plate, fitting and flange that arrives on site comes with paperwork that claims it is what the purchase order asked for. The mill test certificate (MTC), or material test certificate, is the key document. Reading one quickly and critically is a basic skill for QA/QC and inspection engineers, and it is where many wrong-material problems are first caught, or missed.
Short answer: First check the certificate type: EN 10204 3.1 (validated by the manufacturer's independent inspection representative) or 3.2 (also validated by the purchaser's representative or an official inspector), whichever was ordered. Then check that the specification, grade, size and heat number match the order and the item, that chemistry and mechanical results meet the specification, and that any extra requirements such as impact tests or sour-service limits were actually tested.
EN 10204 document types
| Type | What it is (our summary) | Who validates it |
|---|---|---|
| 2.1 | Declaration of compliance with the order, with no test results | Manufacturer |
| 2.2 | Test report with results from non-specific inspection (typical of production, not necessarily this delivery) | Manufacturer |
| 3.1 | Inspection certificate with results from specific inspection of the products supplied | The manufacturer's authorised inspection representative, independent of the manufacturing department |
| 3.2 | Inspection certificate as 3.1, with specific inspection witnessed or verified | Both the manufacturer's independent representative and the purchaser's authorised representative or an official inspector |
For pressure equipment and piping in oil and gas, 3.1 is common and 3.2 is often specified for critical items. The type is a purchase requirement: a 3.1 certificate is not acceptable where the order asked for 3.2.
What to check, line by line
- Certificate type matches the order (3.1 or 3.2).
- Product, specification and grade, for example ASTM A106 Grade B, plus size, schedule or thickness, match the purchase order.
- Heat number on the certificate matches the marking on the item. This is the traceability link; without it the certificate proves nothing about that item.
- Chemical analysis is within the specification's limits, including restricted elements your project may limit further.
- Mechanical properties: yield strength, tensile strength, elongation and hardness meet the specification minimums and any maximums.
- Impact tests, where required, are at the right temperature and meet the energy requirements.
- Heat treatment, hydrotest and NDT were carried out as the specification and order require.
- Supplementary requirements, such as sour-service hardness limits to NACE MR0175/ISO 15156 or HIC testing, are shown as tested, not just stated.
- Validation: signed by the right person for the certificate type.
Carbon equivalent: a quick weldability check
Many specifications limit the carbon equivalent (CE), which indicates how hardenable the steel is and how much care welding needs. A widely used formula is the IIW carbon equivalent:
CE (IIW) = C + Mn/6 + (Cr + Mo + V)/5 + (Ni + Cu)/15
Using the mock certificate's values: 0.18 + 0.92/6 + (0.05 + 0.01 + 0.002)/5 + (0.04 + 0.08)/15 = about 0.35. Compare with any CE limit in your specification; higher values may call for preheat or other welding controls.
Red flags
- Heat number does not match the item, or the item is not marked at all.
- Values identical across many certificates for different heats, or suspiciously round numbers.
- "Complies with" statements without results where results were required (a 2.1 presented as a 3.1).
- Missing supplementary tests that the order required, such as impact or HIC tests.
- Photocopies of photocopies, altered or illegible documents.
- A certificate type or validator that does not match what the order specified.
When anything looks wrong, quarantine the material and verify, for example with positive material identification. See our guide to PMI and API RP 578.
Learn more with EIM
EIM's live Material Selection and Failure Analysis course with Mr. Deepak Rawtal covers material grades, mechanical properties, corrosion resistance and refinery design references; check the course page for the next batch. For companies, EIM's inspection services include vendor and source inspection, where certificate review is a core task. EIM is an independent training provider.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between EN 10204 3.1 and 3.2?
Both report results from specific inspection of the products supplied. A 3.1 is validated by the manufacturer's authorised representative independent of manufacturing; a 3.2 is also validated by the purchaser's authorised representative or an official inspector.
Is a 2.2 certificate acceptable for pressure equipment?
Usually not where the specification calls for 3.1 or 3.2, because a 2.2 reports non-specific results rather than results for the items supplied. Follow your code and purchase specification.
What is a heat number?
The identifier of the melt the steel came from. It links the physical item to its certificate and test results.
What is carbon equivalent?
A value calculated from the chemical composition that indicates hardenability and weldability. The IIW formula is CE = C + Mn/6 + (Cr + Mo + V)/5 + (Ni + Cu)/15.
What should I do if a certificate looks suspicious?
Quarantine the material, raise it with the supplier, and verify the material independently, for example with PMI and, if needed, laboratory testing.
Sources
- EN 10204:2004, Metallic products: Types of inspection documents. Summarised, not quoted.
- IIW carbon equivalent formula, as widely published.
- Mock certificate prepared by EIM; all values invented. Checked 7 October 2026.
Free mock tests
Preparing for an API, AMPP (NACE), CSWIP or CMRP exam?
Choose your certification and try a free mock test.
SMRP


